Tuesday, September 23, 2008

Japanese is now the fourth official language

Freedom of speech in Singapore is a joke. Things like this remind me why I've become a 'reluctant migrant'.

Red card on race issues at Speakers' Corner
Police turn down estate agent's application to speak on Tamil language issues

By Zakir Hussain

Those who want to give speeches at Speakers' Corner need only to register online. Despite the liberalisation of rules, topics on race and religion remain out of bounds. -- BH FILE PHOTO
POLICE have warned a real estate agent, who had planned to go to Speakers' Corner today to talk about the use of Tamil in public signs, against doing so.
A police spokesman said in a statement to The Straits Times yesterday: 'Police communicated its concerns to the applicant that the topic of his speech is a sensitive one impinging on race.
'The applicant then informed the police that he would not proceed with the speech.'
The spokesman added: 'Singapore is a multi-ethnic society and maintaining community harmony is a key imperative that we must not take for granted.'
The police caution comes three weeks after rules at the Hong Lim Park venue were liberalised.
With the change, speakers need only to register online at the National Parks Board (NParks) website any time before they speak and state the topic of their speech or demonstration.
Only race and religion remain out of bounds.
The person who applied to speak on the Tamil language issue is Mr Thamilselvan Karuppaya, 40.
He told The Straits Times he had registered at the NParks website over the weekend, on behalf of a group of 10 friends.
He received a call on Tuesday from the police, he said, telling him he had to apply for a Public Entertainment Licence. He did so.
Yesterday, he found out his application had been rejected.
Asked by The Straits Times if he was still going to the Speakers' Corner to speak today, Mr Thamilselvan retorted: 'You expect me to give a talk and go to jail?'
He then added: 'But we are finding a way to get a licence approved. We are not going to keep quiet on this topic.'
Police said NParks had referred the applicant to them as 'NParks had assessed that the speech was closely related to race and, hence, required express approval from the police as it does not fall under the exemption conditions for speeches at Speakers' Corner'.
Said its spokesman: 'Police would like to remind the public that a Public Entertainment Licence is still required for those who wish to hold events concerning race and religion at Speakers' Corner.'
In the past two days, a number of Singaporeans - Tamils and non-Tamils - received SMSes telling them about today's aborted event at Speakers' Corner.
The SMS, which was also received by The Straits Times, called on 'all Singaporeans to tell the Singapore Tourism Board to 'Put Back Tamil' on the signages at Changi Airport and directional signboards all over the island'.
The police yesterday urged people who had received the SMS to 'take note that the applicant has informed the police he would not be proceeding with the event'.
Earlier this year, Mr Thamilselvan wrote to the Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (CAAS), which runs the airport, about the absence of Tamil signs there.
The CAAS replied last week that directional signs were previously only in English. From April 2005, they were also in Chinese, Malay and Japanese, to cater to the large number of visitors speaking those languages.
As English was India's second language, it was advised by the Singapore Tourism Board that English signs were sufficient.
Mr Thamilselvan was not satisfied with this, saying he was asking only for the four official languages to be reflected.
Contacted by The Straits Times, another Tamil housing agent, Mr N. Rajendran, 60, felt a distinction should be made between commercial and official recognition of Tamil.
Lawyer R. Ravindran, 48, a former MP, said: 'It is still premature to allow issues such as race, language or religion to be discussed in an open forum. Other channels should have been pursued first.'

Also see...

www.catfall.blogspot.com

12 Comments:

At 2:46 AM, Blogger Thiagesh said...

Freedoms are not absolute..If there are issues which could inflame racial/religious passions, i think it should be regulated.

But thats just the patriot in me talking haha...:P

 
At 7:55 AM, Blogger my life.... said...

Well i agree with you.. The problem with them is that Tamil is a language and the arguement shld be over a language rather than a race/ religion. Just like our working language here in Singapore is English. But does that makes us Anglos? Since there are 4 official languages, there is no doubt to include Tamil as one of the languages in the sign boards. The sad thing is that our Indian community itself fails to advocate and support the idea.

 
At 8:01 AM, Blogger my life.... said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 10:42 AM, Blogger Kartik Menon said...

I believe in social responsibility as well and I think there definitely needs to be some regulation (especially with sensitive issues which could potentially threaten the social stability of the country).

However, in this particular instance, I feel the reaction to the situation by the police was completely not warranted. I really don't think it was a racial issue although it seems like it is developing into one (based on several conversations I've had with other very frustrated Indians over the last week). Those who wanted to speak, had a very valid argument and were using proper channels to voice their concerns.

Personally, incidents such as this make me feel marginalised in my own country. It offends me not to see Tamil represented in the signs of Changi Airport. While Singapore has a very special place in my heart, I sometimes feel like I'd rather be a foreigner in another country than be subjected to feel like a 2nd class citizen in my own home.

And Lalitha, you are right. It is saddening to see that support is lacking amongst a small portion of the Indian community(e.g. that guy who wrote in to the forum page!)

Kartik

 
At 7:04 PM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

Language arguments are so interesting. The US doesn't have an official language and there are plenty of arguments for how English should ALWAYS hold prominence...and your country has four official languages and doesn't even represent one in a place a public as the airport...so interesting...

 
At 9:18 PM, Blogger Kartik Menon said...

Haha...Emily, it is funny how an American like yourself sees this situation as a no-brainer and yet, those within the system can't understand what the issue is about.

 
At 9:19 PM, Blogger Kartik Menon said...

This comment has been removed by the author.

 
At 6:40 AM, Blogger my life.... said...

hey Kartik, hw are u man? hows saras?

 
At 7:12 AM, Blogger my life.... said...

Hey Kartik, happy birthday to u :) May god bless u :)

 
At 7:07 PM, Blogger Kartik Menon said...

Hey Lalitha...I've been good that..Saras is doing well too..how are things at your end?

 
At 4:09 AM, Anonymous ideas negocios rentables said...

Your blog is very informative and provide lots of ideas and inspiration. Thanks for sharing your knowledge

 
At 1:13 AM, Blogger genuine_pills said...

Nice post. I just have nothing to contribute as I thiknk this is an intricate and cultural topic. But nevertheless I was impress wit the ides. This is how the internet connects us all together and share ideas even if we are far away from each other. By the way, you might want to use the internet not just for blogging but also make money online by joining an affiliate program. This is the power of the internet. You can stay home and still be an enterprenuer

 

Post a Comment

<< Home